Re: Digital to Analog downloading Question ?

On Apr 10, 8:27 pm, "Harry Lavo" <hl...@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
> wrote:
> Isn't it marvelous, therefore, that with all the variety the human brain
is
> rarely fooled into mistaking reproduced sound from live music.

The key word here is "rarely", which allows for the observable fact
that, occasionally we are indeed fooled.  If we can be fooled at all
it is only then a matter of figuring out how to fool ourselves
reliably.  A technical problem that is certainly solvable.

In fact we can do it intentionally and we know how to do it.  AR did
it reliably back in the 1960's for gosh sakes!

We just don't know how to do it in a domestic environment with
domestically practical equipment yet.

> Which
> suggests why comparing components to our "gestalt recollection" of what
> makes music sound "live" is a better standard than comparing two pieces
of
> "sound".

It doesn't even suggest "that", let alone suggesting "why".